Micellar Water vs. Cleansing Oil vs. Cleansing Balm: What Should You Choose?

micellar water vs. cleansing oil vs. cleansing balm what's the difference

Share This Post:

Note: As an affiliate, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post. This helps support my work, but it won't cost you any extra. For more information, please read my full disclosure here.

When it comes to picking your skin’s BFF from micellar water, cleansing oil, or cleansing balm, it’s like, “Where do I even start?”

Totally get it – we’ve all been there, scanning the skincare aisle, a bit lost but ready for some action. It’s like a ‘choose your own adventure’ for your face, right?

Finding the right cleanser is kind of a personal quest – I’ve been there, done that, and got the T-shirt. Trust me, every little ‘whoops’ with a product you try is just another step toward nailing down what your skin loves.

I’m here to spill the tea on my own skincare wins and blunders to help you dodge the skincare hurdles and make your routine a whole lot smoother and more fun. Let’s get to it!

Micellar Water

micellar water

What’s micellar water?

Micellar water is this super gentle cleanser that’s got these tiny molecules called micelles. Think of them as tiny dirt magnets. They’re mixed in soft water with some mild surfactants and usually some hydrating goodies like glycerin. I love how it’s gentle yet effective, and it doesn’t strip my skin of its natural oils.

How it works on the skin

When applied to the skin, micellar water acts like a magnet. The hydrophobic part of the micelles attracts and traps skin impurities, oil, and makeup, while the hydrophilic part allows these to be swept away without harsh rubbing. This dual-action process ensures a thorough cleanse without disrupting the skin’s natural lipid barrier.

Pros of micellar water

Micellar water has several notable advantages that make it a favorite in many skincare routines. Its gentle formulation ensures that it is soft on the skin without causing irritation, making it suitable for all skin types. 

A major convenience factor is that there’s no need to rinse it off after use, which simplifies the skincare process, especially when you’re tired or in a hurry. 

In terms of hydration, micellar water is excellent as it leaves the skin feeling moisturized and refreshed, not tight or dry, maintaining the skin’s natural moisture balance. 

Personally, I find micellar water incredibly travel-friendly. On trips, it’s my go-to choice for facial cleansing since it eliminates the need to visit the restroom just for a face wash. This hassle-free feature makes it perfect for on-the-go use, whether you’re traveling, at the gym, or need a quick refreshment throughout the day.

Cons of micellar water

While micellar water is a popular choice in skincare routines, it does have its cons. One significant limitation is its inability to effectively remove heavy or waterproof makeup, which may necessitate a stronger cleanser or makeup remover. 

Additionally, for those with oily or acne-prone skin, micellar water might not provide the deep cleansing needed to remove all impurities and residual makeup, often requiring a follow-up with a traditional cleanser. 

Although it’s great for surface cleaning, micellar water doesn’t deeply penetrate pores, making it less effective against blackheads and excess sebum.

Skin types suitable for micellar water

Micellar water is a versatile skincare product that’s suitable for a wide range of skin types, making it a valuable addition to virtually any skincare routine.

  • Sensitive skin: Perhaps one of the biggest beneficiaries of micellar water is sensitive skin. Its gentle nature means it cleanses without causing irritation or redness, a common concern for those with sensitive skin. The lack of harsh chemicals and alcohol in many formulations makes it a safe choice.
  • Oily and acne-prone skin: For those battling oily skin or prone to acne, micellar water can be a good option. It effectively removes excess oil and surface impurities without over-drying the skin, which can trigger even more oil production.
  • Dry skin: Micellar water is also a boon for dry skin types. Its hydrating properties ensure that the skin doesn’t feel stripped of its natural oils after cleansing. This aspect helps maintain the skin’s natural moisture barrier, which is crucial for dry skin.
  • Combination skin: If you have combination skin, micellar water is an excellent choice due to its balancing nature. It cleanses the oily zones without aggravating the dry areas, providing an even, gentle cleansing experience across different areas of the face.
  • Normal skin: For those with normal skin, micellar water is a convenient, effective cleansing option that maintains skin health without much fuss. It’s gentle enough to keep the skin in good condition without the need for specialized care.

How to use micellar water

  • Grab a bottle of micellar water and some cotton pads.
  • Pour a bit of micellar water onto a cotton pad until it’s damp.
  • Use the cotton pad to gently wipe your face. Start from the middle and move outwards and upwards. This technique helps to not drag your skin downwards, keeping your face looking fresh and uplifted.
  • If you’re wearing makeup or your face is particularly dirty, you might need a few cotton pads. Keep going until the pad looks clean after you wipe.

👍 Best micellar water

La Roche-Posay Micellar Cleansing Water
$17.99 ($1.33 / Fl Oz)

For anyone with sensitive skin searching for a top-notch cleanser, I've discovered a micellar water that is a true standout. It's impressively gentle and boasts a cleanse level of 9.5 out of 10, effectively removing almost all makeup, including waterproof types. This product is unscented and leaves the skin feeling hydrated, not dry—remarkable for a cleanser that's both oil-free and alcohol-free. It's an excellent pick for all skin types, and especially ideal for those with sensitive skin.

BUY ON AMAZON
09/30/2024 08:37 am GMT
Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water
$18.99 ($1.14 / Fl Oz)

The first micellar water I ever tried won me over completely, and I've been in love with it since day one. With a cleansing effectiveness that I'd rate at 8 out of 10, it's incredibly gentle on the skin, which is a big win in my book. It's the kind of product that even my cousin, who has eczema, uses religiously. She's found it to be so kind to her sensitive skin, never causing any breakouts or irritation. This micellar water has become a trusted staple in our skincare routines, and it's something we both reach for when we need reliable, gentle cleansing.

BUY ON AMAZON
09/30/2024 08:54 am GMT
Comfort Zone Essential Micellar Water
$46.00 ($6.76 / Fl Oz)


I've recently made the switch to a new micellar water, and I have to say, it's become the star of my skincare routine. Its gentle formula effortlessly removes stubborn makeup while being incredibly gentle on my skin. Unlike some other options I've tried, this one manages to cleanse thoroughly without leaving my skin feeling dry; however, it doesn't have the slight moisturizing effect that my previous go-to had, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. It just leaves my skin feeling pure and clean.

I know it comes with a higher price tag compared to others, but trust me, it's absolutely worth it. The quality and results speak for themselves, and that's why I find myself repurchasing it time and time again.

BUY ON AMAZON
09/30/2024 09:27 am GMT

Cleansing Oil

cleansing oil

What’s cleansing oil?

Cleansing oil is a skincare product specifically designed for cleaning the face. Unlike regular oils that you might find in your kitchen, like olive or coconut oil, cleansing oil is formulated with a mix of skincare oils and an essential component called an emulsifier. 

The role of these oils is to dissolve impurities, excess sebum, and makeup on your skin.

The key difference that sets cleansing oils apart from regular oils is the emulsifier. This ingredient allows the cleansing oil to mix with water and form a milky emulsion. 

When you rinse your face with water, this emulsion along with all the dirt and makeup is easily washed away, leaving your skin clean and without any greasy residue. 

This is SUPERRRR crucial because, without an emulsifier, regular oils don’t mix with water and can be difficult to wash off. They might leave behind a residue that can clog pores and potentially lead to breakouts, especially for those with acne-prone skin.

How it works on the skin

When you rub cleansing oil onto your skin, it sticks to the day’s oil, dirt, and even makeup. Since the cleansing oil and the stuff on your face are both oily, they sort of cling together.

As you massage the oil on your skin, it picks up all the dirt and grime. This includes the tough stuff like waterproof makeup and sunscreen, which can be really hard to get off otherwise.

Then comes the cool part. When you add a bit of water, the cleansing oil changes a bit. It turns into this milky liquid. This happens because of something in the oil called an emulsifier – it’s what helps the oil mix with water. 

When you rinse your face, all the oil mixed with the day’s dirt and gunk just washes away. It leaves your skin feeling clean but not dry or tight, because it doesn’t take away the good oils your skin needs.

Pros of cleansing oil

Cleansing oil has a bunch of great things going for it that make it a favorite for lots of people. 

It’s awesome at getting rid of tough makeup and sunscreen, so you don’t have to scrub your face too hard. 

It’s also really kind to your skin, especially if you’ve got dry skin. Instead of leaving your face feeling all tight and dry after washing, it keeps things nice and moisturized. 

Another cool thing is it’s super gentle, which is a big plus if you have sensitive skin that gets upset easily. It doesn’t strip away all your skin’s natural oils, which is important for keeping your skin healthy and happy. 

Plus, using it feels kind of like a mini spa treatment right in your bathroom, so that’s always a nice little bonus to end the day with. Every time I use an oil-based cleanser for my face, I feel really relaxed after a long day. 

Cons of cleansing oil

Cleansing oil, while great for many, does have some drawbacks to consider. One of the main issues is that it might not be the best fit for everyone, especially if you have very oily or acne-prone skin. 

Because it’s oil-based, some people find that it can leave their skin feeling a bit too greasy, and it may even contribute to breakouts in certain cases. Also, if you’re not a fan of the feeling of oil on your skin, you might not enjoy using it as much.

Another point is that it requires a bit more effort to use correctly. You need to massage it into your skin and then add water to emulsify it before rinsing it off. This extra step might be a bit much for those who prefer a quick and simple skincare routine. 

And speaking of rinsing, sometimes it can be a bit tricky to wash off all the oil completely, leaving a residue behind.

While many cleansing oils are made with natural ingredients, some might contain synthetic additives or fragrances that can irritate sensitive skin

Skin types suitable for cleansing oil

  • Dry skin: Great for keeping your skin moisturized. It cleans without making your skin feel tight or dry.
  • Normal skin: Works well by cleaning your skin gently and keeping it soft without removing too much natural oil.
  • Combination skin: Helpful for balancing oily spots like the T-zone while keeping the drier areas like cheeks moisturized.
  • Oily skin: Surprisingly good for removing excess oil gently. If you prefer your skin to still feel moist and not overly dry after cleansing, you might want to consider trying a cleansing oil. It can cleanse effectively without being harsh or stripping your skin’s natural moisture.
  • Acne-prone skin: Be careful here. Some people find it helps, but others might get breakouts. It’s best to test it on a small area first or check with a dermatologist.

How to use cleansing oil

  • Gently massage it into your entire face for about 45-60 seconds. This helps lift off the dirt and makeup.
  • After the initial massage, wet your hands and continue massaging your face for an additional 30 seconds. This helps turn the oil into a milky texture.
  • Rinse your face thoroughly with water to remove the oil along with any dirt and makeup.
  • Try not to keep the oil on your face for more than 3-5 minutes in total to avoid any potential irritation.

Related post: Double Cleansing: The Secret Weapon Against Breakouts And Pollution

👍 Best cleansing oil

Beverly Kose Softymo Speedy Cleansing Oil
$9.98 ($1.28 / Fl Oz)

You'll find this cleansing oil to be an absolute game-changer for removing makeup effortlessly, particularly handy during your shower routine. It's designed to dissolve makeup quickly, so it's super efficient. Just a little note when using it at the sink - it might be a tad messy, but that's just because it's really getting the job done. The product itself is gentle on your skin. It leaves your face feeling smooth and fresh, without any of that tightness some cleansers can cause.

BUY ON AMAZON
09/30/2024 09:48 am GMT
ma:nyo Pure Cleansing Oil
$28.96 ($4.32 / Fl Oz)

This cleansing oil is all over TikTok for a reason – it's a bestseller from Olive Young and totally lives up to the hype. Jumped on the bandwagon myself (thanks, TikTok, haha!) and seriously, it's love at first cleanse. Unlike other oils, it doesn't strip your skin dry. It's free from any scent, which is a huge plus, and it rinses off effortlessly. Noticed my skin texture getting smoother and my face feels oh-so-soft after. If you're looking for a cleanser that's gentle yet effective, you've gotta check this one out!

BUY ON AMAZON
09/30/2024 09:52 am GMT
Dermalogica Precleanse Oil Cleanser
$49.00 ($9.61 / Fl Oz)

This pre-cleansing oil has been my go-to for years, especially during those times when my skin is having a tough breakout phase. Its gentle, watery texture is perfect for a soothing massage without ever causing any irritation or worsening my breakouts. It washes off so easily, leaving no residue, just clean, happy skin. I wholeheartedly recommend it for any skin type, even for those with sensitive skin. It's been a reliable part of my skincare arsenal, and I'm confident it could be a game-changer for you too!

BUY ON AMAZON
09/30/2024 09:58 am GMT

Cleansing Balm

cleansing balm

What’s cleansing balm?

Cleansing balm is a solid or semi-solid balm but melts into a smooth, oil-like texture as you apply it to your skin. 

Made from a blend of oils and emollients, cleansing balms are effective at dissolving makeup, sunscreen, and daily grime without stripping the skin’s natural oils. 

They’re known for their deep-cleansing ability, leaving the skin feeling soft and hydrated. Cleansing balms are popular for their luxurious feel and are often favored for their nourishing ingredients, making them a great choice for a gentle yet thorough facial cleanse.

How it differs from cleansing oils

Cleansing balm differs from cleansing oils mainly in its texture and application method. While both are designed to cleanse the skin and remove makeup, their consistency sets them apart.

Cleansing balm starts as a solid or semi-solid in its container. When you scoop it out and apply it to your face, the warmth of your skin transforms it into a silky oil-like consistency. This transformation allows you to massage the product into your skin effectively.

On the other hand, cleansing oils are liquid from the start. They come in a bottle and are typically applied by squirting a small amount into your hands and then massaging directly onto the face.

Pros of cleansing balm

Cleansing balms are great for a number of reasons. They have a unique texture that’s solid in the jar but turns into a smooth oil as you apply it to your face. This makes them really effective at removing all kinds of makeup, even the tough, waterproof stuff, without any hard scrubbing. 

If you have dry skin, you’ll appreciate how cleansing balms clean without leaving your skin feeling dry. Instead, your skin feels soft and moisturized afterward. 

They’re also handy for travel because they’re solid and won’t spill in your bag. Plus, many cleansing balms come packed with extra skin-loving ingredients, so you’re not just cleaning your face, you’re giving it some extra nourishment.

Cons of cleansing balm

For starters, they can be a bit messier and more time-consuming to use compared to liquid cleansers. Because they start as a solid, you need to take the time to warm them up in your hands and then work them into your skin, which can add a few extra minutes to your routine.

Another potential downside is that some cleansing balms may leave a residue on the skin, especially if they’re not rinsed off properly. This could be a concern for those with oily or acne-prone skin, as any residual product might contribute to clogged pores and breakouts.

Because cleansing balms are rich and nourishing, they might feel too heavy for those with oily skin types. The texture, which is part of their appeal, can be a bit too much for those who prefer a lighter, more refreshing cleanse.

Skin types suitable for cleansing balm

  • Dry skin: Cleansing balms are excellent for dry skin because they clean without stripping away the skin’s natural oils, leaving it feeling soft and moisturized.
  • Normal skin: They work well for normal skin types, offering a balanced cleanse without causing dryness or excessive oiliness.
  • Combination skin: Cleansing balms can help balance combination skin by effectively cleaning oily areas while keeping drier parts hydrated.
  • Sensitive skin: Many cleansing balms are formulated with gentle ingredients, making them suitable for sensitive skin that can easily get irritated.
  • Mature skin: These balms can be particularly beneficial for mature skin, as they clean while providing a dose of nourishment, helping to maintain a youthful appearance.

How to use cleansing balm

  • Begin with both your hands and face completely dry.
  • Take a small amount of the cleansing balm using a clean spatula or your fingers.
  • Gently rub the balm between your fingertips to warm it up until it becomes an oil-like texture.
  • Apply the balm to your dry face and massage it gently. This helps to dissolve makeup, sunscreen, and impurities.
  • Pay extra attention to areas with heavy makeup or stubborn products.
  • Wet your hands slightly and continue massaging your face. The balm will emulsify, turning into a milky texture.
  • Rinse your face with lukewarm water until all the balm and impurities are washed away.

👍 Best cleansing balm

Farmacy Cleansing Balm
$36.00 ($10.59 / Fl Oz)

The first product I ever tried from Farmacy was their moisturizer, which I absolutely adored, so I was keen to give their cleansing balm a go too. True to form, it's incredibly gentle on the skin. Applying it feels so smooth, and it just glides over the face, effortlessly melting away makeup. After rinsing, my skin always feels fantastic – it's hydrated, clear, and never shows signs of dryness or irritation.

BUY ON AMAZON
09/30/2024 10:13 am GMT
ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm
$18.00 ($25.71 / Ounce)

This cleansing balm is a fantastic find for anyone who struggles with removing waterproof mascara or long-wear makeup. Just apply it directly to dry skin and massage in gentle, circular motions to let the balm work its magic. It leaves the skin feeling soft and refreshed, never tight or parched. When you're done, a simple rinse with warm water sweeps away the remnants, and your face feels nourished and clean.

BUY ON AMAZON
09/30/2024 10:21 am GMT
Clinique TAKE THE DAY OFF CLEANSING BALM

When talking about cleansing balms, it would be a miss not to mention the one that's become a staple in my routine. Ever since I started using it, I've really grasped why people rave about it. I apply a bit of the balm on my face, gently rubbing it in. Then, I add water, and it's like everything from foundation to the stubborn eyeliner just dissolves away. It's quite the experience seeing how far just a little of this product can go. Although it's fragrance-free, which is great for sensitive noses, it has this incredibly subtle scent, like natural oils, that you'll only catch if you're really up close to the jar.

BUY ON AMAZON

More About Skincare Topic:

10 Must-Try Ways To Use Sheet Masks For Glowing Skin

Is A Toner Really Necessary For Your Skin?

Should You Pop Your Pimples Or Leave Them Alone?

more to explore...

A lovely corner is where you can discover fantastic tips about college life, personal development, relationships, skincare, and wellness!